Open Letter to the Prime Minister: No Return to Humberside
Alliance for Yorkshire
To: The Rt Hon Andy Burnham MP, Prime Minister
No. 10, North, Manchester
Dear Prime Minister,
As the government reviews the governance and geography of Hull and East Yorkshire and the Greater Lincolnshire mayoral authorities, beginning in May 2027, I am writing to ask you to rule out any return to a single Humberside authority.
There is a distinction between working together across the Humber and putting two distinct areas under one political administration. We support the former. We oppose the latter.
Humberside was created in 1974, bringing together parts of Yorkshire and Lincolnshire. Following years of dissatisfaction, it was abolished. The new county did not reflect local identity or history.
The creation of the Hull and East Yorkshire Combined Authority, with its first mayor elected in May 2025, offers an opportunity to build on the area’s own identity and give it a stronger voice. It should not become a stepping stone towards recreating an arrangement that people have already rejected.
Yorkshire's boundaries have changed over the years. The West Riding was divided, and places such as Saddleworth, Barnoldswick, Earby and Sedbergh were transferred elsewhere. Middlesbrough has been associated with the North Riding, Teesside, Cleveland, its own unitary authority and now the Tees Valley Combined Authority.
These changes have not necessarily changed how people feel about where they belong. Good government should recognise that sense of belonging, not repeatedly dismantle it.
The Yorkshire Society’s Big Yorkshire Conversation in 2021, involving more than 4,500 people and analysed with the University of Hull, found strong support for Yorkshire identity and the White Rose. It was not a scientific opinion poll, but it usefully indicates how strong that attachment is.
The same consideration applies across the Humber. Communities such as Grimsby, Cleethorpes, Scunthorpe, Barton and Brigg have their own identities and local loyalties. They should not be expected to accept a new political identity simply because they share economic interests with Hull and East Yorkshire.
The Humber Bridge connects two banks; it does not make them one region.
Cooperation, not consolidation
The Humberside Police and Crime Commissioner and Deputy Commissioner have raised concerns about the present arrangements and the difficulties of working across different administrative boundaries. They also argue that a single Humber-wide authority could help realise the area’s economic potential.
We agree that cooperation needs to be effective. But that does not mean political boundaries need to be changed.
The proposed abolition of Police and Crime Commissioners in May 2028, with responsibilities transferring to mayors where possible and otherwise to Policing and Crime Boards involving elected council leaders, is particularly relevant.
Existing cross-boundary cooperation does not require recreating the former county authority.
An elected Police and Crime Commissioner oversees Humberside Police, and a statutory Police and Crime Panel scrutinises them. The panel consists of ten councillors representing the four constituent councils and two independent members. Its role is to scrutinise the Commissioner’s decisions and actions, rather than to direct or manage the police force itself.
Similarly, Humberside Fire Authority brings together the four councils, with 22 appointed councillors and the Police and Crime Commissioner. Its membership comprises eight representatives from East Riding, six from Hull and four each from North Lincolnshire and North East Lincolnshire. Since 1996, it has provided a common fire and rescue service across these areas.
These arrangements demonstrate that services can be organised and scrutinised across council boundaries without restoring a single tier of county government. Where improvements are needed, the government should first examine how to strengthen existing joint arrangements rather than create a new Humber authority.
Humberside Police serves four council areas across two mayoral authorities: Hull City Council and East Riding of Yorkshire Council within Hull and East Yorkshire, and North Lincolnshire and North East Lincolnshire within Greater Lincolnshire. Neither mayor alone can provide democratic oversight of the whole force.
The government's January 2026 policing white paper proposes policing and crime boards for circumstances where policing governance cannot be transferred to a single mayoral authority. We believe Humberside is one of those situations.
We therefore propose a permanent statutory Humber Policing and Crime Board, comprising the mayors of Hull and East Yorkshire and Greater Lincolnshire, together with the leaders of Hull City Council, East Riding of Yorkshire Council, North Lincolnshire Council and North East Lincolnshire Council, with independent co-optees where appropriate.
Consistent with the government's proposed model, the Board should have the powers to appoint, suspend and dismiss the chief constable; set the police force budget and policing precept; and establish the police and crime plan. It should appoint a designated Policing and Crime Lead, be supported by a secretariat, meet transparently, publish its scrutiny of policing performance and provide clear democratic accountability for the whole force area.
This would provide effective policing governance across both banks without creating another general-purpose political authority.
We can also look beyond England. Scotland has its own government and national police service, while neighbouring English police forces have different governing arrangements. Yet cooperation across the border takes place through mutual assistance and joint operations. If different systems can work together across the Scottish and English border, there is no reason why the authorities on either side of the Humber cannot do the same.
The Humber Leadership Board and the Humber Economic Strategy 2025–2035 already provide a basis for joint work on energy, ports, logistics and flood risk. There is considerable scope to strengthen this partnership between the two mayors and the councils on both banks.
Research conducted in 2024 for the Association of Police and Crime Commissioners, published in 2025 as Towards Better Local Partnership Systems in England and Wales, together with its Towards Better Partnerships: Deep Dives report, examined Humberside as an example of how complex partnership arrangements are managed.
It identified concerns about duplication across local partnership systems but also recorded how Humberside developed a regional roundtable to streamline collaboration and reduce duplication, alongside reforms to the Local Criminal Justice Board which replaced potentially duplicative groups with a single Operations Board.
Different administrative boundaries create difficulties that are best overcome through cooperation, rather than by changing the boundaries themselves.
The cost and disruption argument
The Commissioner has also raised concerns about the costs and disruption of the present arrangements. We ask the government to publish a costed comparison of improved joint governance with the creation of a new Humber authority, including the costs of establishing and maintaining it.
Creating a new political authority would itself involve organisational change, additional administration and disruption. Why undertake that when the government is already proposing a Policing and Crime Board model specifically to deal with policing responsibilities that cross mayoral boundaries?
We should not confuse the need for better cooperation with a need for political consolidation.
The government's wider police reforms may also lead to fewer, larger forces. Whatever changes take place, local policing must remain accessible and accountable. There should be a clear local policing presence, a named local commander and proper democratic scrutiny.
We ask the Government to:
Rule out any return to a single Humber-wide political authority, and make clear that the review will respect the distinct identities of Hull and East Yorkshire and the communities of Lincolnshire.
Publish the terms of reference for the 2027 review, including how local identity, public consent, costs and the effectiveness of existing arrangements will be assessed.
Confirm that the government's proposed Policing and Crime Board model will be applied to Humberside, bringing together both mayors and the leaders of the four councils in a permanent statutory arrangement with the powers and resources to provide effective policing governance and democratic scrutiny across the whole force area.
Confirm how Humberside Police will be governed and scrutinised after the 2028 changes, ensuring that local accountability is maintained and that policing arrangements are not used to dictate political boundaries.
Devolution should bring decisions closer to people, not create larger structures that make local identity and accountability harder to recognise.
We have had our county cut up once. Please do not give the East Riding away a second time.
Stamus ut unum — We stand as one.
Yours sincerely,
John Hall
Alliance for Yorkshire
Harrogate, HG3 1GA
yorkshirealliance.com